Hey guys... this is soopa... the owner/admin of AcuraZine.
I tried to register last night... but ya'll still have not activated my account... so amir has been kind enough to loan me his.
Let me first respond to the original poster:
I think its safe to say that both Acura & Audi vehicles have their fair share of problems. There's not much debate that can honestly be put into that. Its plain fact unfortunately. Neither Audi nor Acura have been at the pinnacle of reliability for some time. No point in any of us lying to ourselves about that.
As for the behavior of TL owners in that thread:
You must realize that many of the individuals of our 3G TL forum are brand new Acura owners. They just invested as much as 40K of their hard earned salary in a brand new vehicle.
The original poster in that thread came in with an obvious bias, and quite emotional anti-Acura opinion.
Whether is opinion is valid or not. The response is typical and as is expected by people who just made a major investment in the vehicle being attacked.
Audi owners would react in a similar fashion... a quick search on this forum or even this thread itself exhibits that fact.
I think all of us have to rationalize our purchases to ourselves. In doing so we must highlight the pluses of our intended purchase and find minuses with the alternatives.
Its plain idiotic not to recognize that... and more so to fight about it.
As for AcuraZine, the name, the history, etc.
Jesal got it right.
The community has its roots back to 1999. When we started A-TL.
Later A-CL. Then A-TSX.
Eventually, with the massive success of our three communities... we decided it was time to brand them under an umbrella.
We created the AcuraZine name just over one year ago. It is still in its infancy and being slowly integrated into our communities.
In all honesty, I was completely unaware of the existence of "AudiZine" at the time the name was created.
To this day, most members of my community are unaware of this fact as well.
However, had I been aware of the name I would be happy to admit AudiZine as my inspiration.
AudiZine seems like a fine site from my limited exposure since Amir/Jesal first made me aware of it several months back.
Were I an Audi owner, I would most likely frequent AudiZine as I share the same sentiment with most of you in regards to AudiWorld.
In reality however, the name evolved from several points.
When we began the journey, our original motivation had been to create a print magazine. This is how the AcuraZine name first became a possibility. Beyond that, we had, at the time, intended to create a Nissan Z community as well... and nissanZine had a great ring to it.
We later abandoned both of those concepts... but still realized an umbrella was needed for our Acura communities.
We matched several names to the following criteria:
1. We wanted a unique name that didn't sound too generic (aka "-World" or "-Club")
2. The name needed to to be "wearable". That is... look good and sound good on merchandise. We don't want our members walking around with t-shirts sporting lame generic slogans like "AudiWorld" etc. :D
3. We needed a name that stood apart from the incredibly cramped crowd of Honda & Acura communities.
4. The name needed to look good in the same type face as our original ACURA-CL/TL etc style.
I'm sure there were more, the whole process was well over a year in the making. But thats what I recall of the top of my head.
When I finally started to take the "AcuraZine" name seriously... I did some research on the web to find anyone else using the ZINE suffix.
In this research I found many sites, however, not this one.
One of the sites I did find, that I actually had frequented quite often but never managed to add 2+2 was mozillaZine.
With all this, i decided to go ahead.
I was not aware of AudiZine until sometime this summer. (You guys need to improve your search rankings! ;))
Regardless, were both here now. We may be the largest "*Zine" but you are indeed the original. Of all sites to share a suffix with, I'm happy its this. It could be faaaar worse.
I hope this explanation is sufficient, this entire thread has needlessly diminished to kindergarten level. We're all friends here.
If anything, the existence of both of us will help promote the "ZINE" suffix and perhaps help us both against our real competitors.
Theres no reason an Acura site and an Audi site should have any animosity towards each other. Apples and Oranges.
-soopa
Bookmarks