
Originally Posted by
xeonoex
I did a bunch of research before choosing the RS3. I did consider everything from 2 seaters to sedans. My other favorites are the Lotus Emira and Porsche Cayman. The C8 is a good deal as well. I might have gotten the Alpine A110s if it were available here and had some dealer support. Obviously very different cars compared the the RS3. If you want a manual with four doors, I think the CT4-V is something to consider.
I have no regrets with the RS3. It really does do it all well. Daily driving, track driving, insane acceleration and grip, all with 4 doors and pretty good gas mileage. Less engagement in the driving feel, I'd say about the same in playfulness, and the engine does sound awesome.
Funny you should mention this...
I am (like many enthusiasts) purchasing my swan song car. Everything, as you said, from RS7 down to Miata and GT86. Always found a fatal flaw:
- RS7/M5 CS - too large and heavy and above my budget
- R8/911/AMG GT - too expensive to maintain and above my budget
- F Type / Afla Quad - too scared about reliability (says alot coming from a German car buyer...)
- Mustang Mach 1 - can't stomach the price and isn't special like a GT350, also very heavy for a sports car
- Camaro/Challenger - never considered either due to styling/interior preferences, also both are quite heavy like the Mustang
- C63 - new ones are terrible on curb weight and the new hybrid turbo 4 is yuck yuck yuck
- M3/4 - you already know what I am going to say...
- RS5 - boring, literally would rather just get a Macan GTS instead (I already have a fully decked out B9 S5 with all suspension and engine mods, as a daily and find it extremely boring and tame and RS5 is more of the same)
- Miata / GT 86 - by far my favorites but alas... Miata I literally can't fit (6ft 190lbs) and the twins do not have a powertrain I like (interior is also difficult to accept considering how awesome the Miata's is)
- Cayman - unless I get the 981s there is no chance of getting a GTS 4.0 or GT4 allocation anymore, also it's boring looking in non-GT4 body
- Veloster N - no joke drove one of these and LOVED IT, but alas out of production, hated the mismatching pillars due to the 3 door layout (my OCD couldn't handle it), and the Elantra N and Kona N don't do it for me. Despite being FWD I still enjoyed it.
- Civic Type R/Golf GTI/R - while I loved the Mk7 GTI, the news one are very ugly and even with tons of mods won't scratch my 'sports car' itch. Same with the Civic Type R, just too sedate and FWDy for me without the added drama for those concessions like the Veloster N had
- Supra - totally thought I was going to get one considering my adoration of the B58 and it's curb weight is low enough and it drives awesome, but I'd be lying if I didn't admit I HATE the looks of it, seriously not my style...
- C8 Corvette - on paper a perfect match for me, in real life I hate the looks completely and the interior is a HARD pass for me dawg... cool car, just wouldn't personally buy one. Wish I could get a Z06 but don't think that's in my budget haha
All that's left is to check out the 'New' Z (which so far seems to be a bit of a disappointment considering it's price increase) or the Emira. Emira looks amazing and with the M139 and DCT should be a potent combo. But it's everything around the car that is the issue - servicing, parts availability, reliability, etc. But now that it seems Geely is supplying them to an extent, my confidence in purchasing this is a little higher. Still would rather take the Jag though...
So my options are basically RS3 (which I am not too fond of the looks or interior, but seems to be one of the more fun cars of the bunch which I value extremely highly), OR the 'New Z' and Emira. I figure all would likely cost the same in the end - RS3 $70k + $15k in mods, Nismo Z is likely going to be $65k + $15k in mods, and Emira I would likely not mod but has a high sticker price of $85k for the i4 non-FE model. Jag also is around $80k for RWD model but comes with a SC V8 and I prefer the looks to the Emira so I would always have that doubt. In the end, I feel I will puss out on actually buying the Emira or Jag, and the Nismo Z probably won't be to my liking (esp the 9 speed auto, which I heard was particularly not good). I really prefer DCTs so sounds like the RS3 might be my swan song car. The ONLY reason I never considered the old one was despite it's amazing i5 engine, I absolutely hated the FWDiness of it and didn't find the chassis particularly good compared to most RWD cars. But the new one seems to have a completely different personality compared to its predecessor, and I actually like that it traded off some 'ring performance' for what is perceived to be more of a handful and rambunctious driving experience (very similar to the Veloster N in that regard).
What I am trying to say young lads... is the alure of exterior beauty wears off over time, but the personality she brings to the table is what makes her a keeper. And in that regard, the RS3 has that in spades it seems....
Bookmarks