Bought some new 19s for the summer, and after 3 months of them being backordered they finally arrived, just in time for fall

The options im looking at now:
The cheap option - Pirelli PZero Nero GT --$175ea. Have read these are a great value, good performance for the first 20k miles but then the noise builds up. Still, appears to be a damn good deal.
The wildcard - Firestone Firehawk Indy 500 --$205ea. Also read really good things about these, and the positive reviews seem to have raised the price by 50 bucks since a lot of the positive reviews ive found on the forum. if they were 150 it'd be the easy choice, but theyre now in the middle of my price bracket. Heard theyre good and sticky, but highway noise can be obnoxious (or great, depending on the review?)
The cheapest of the top end - Conti Extreme Sport Contact - $240ea. These are obvsiously better tires than the other two, but i care if they are actually 160 bucks more better. not sure i trust any sort of treadlife warranty, as my first set of michelins were rejected after 10k for "unusual wear". they were not unusual, they just wore faster than the guy at discount tire expected and he refused to honor it for michelin.
LEt me know if you have any experience with these, or any other alternatives in the price bracket. Please dont just spam PSS's or PS4S. I know theyre the best. I dont need the best.
thanks
Bookmarks