
Originally Posted by
no thx
Meyle filter is made in taiwan, and it also doesn't come with replacement drain/fill plugs. I would recommend official ZF one for that reason.
Meyle is OEM quality. I've used their filters for . . . decades in various vehicles. So, I went with the FCP Euro kit. FWIW, ZF does not manufacture filters. They are bought from a vendor and rebranded. I'm sure they are excellent quality. Meyle is, too. Mann, Meyle, Hengst and Bosch are all excellent euro-spec filters across the board. I would not hesitate to use any of those brand names.
Lack of new drain/fill plugs are irrelevant to me. They are not the same design as oil plugs. I've never replaced a fill plug on any fluid on any vehicle - auto, truck, industrial or farm engine. Not on differentials, transmissions, gear boxes. I've been wrenching over 50 years.
As to the drain plug - take a good look at the OEM design. It has a built-in o-ring. If it is damaged, you will get a leak right away. They don't wait to leak. Either they seal or they don't. Leave a clean pan under it while doing the fill and top off. If it is going to leak, you'll know it by the time you are ready to button up the bottom trays and bring the car back down off the lift or jack stands.
As to the condition of the old filter, yes, there was quite a bit of fine graphite-looking metallic sludge on the magnets. It was doing its job. Since this is the OEM filter on the car when it left the factory, it saw the original break-in period for the new transmission. It is likely that most of the particles were generated during the first few hundred miles. However, the amount of material on the magnets did cause me to do the "double fill" to further dilute the old fluid still present.
Just one opinion . . .
Bookmarks