Audizine - An Automotive Enthusiast Community

Results 1 to 27 of 27
  1. #1
    Senior Member Two Rings electron bom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 28 2017
    AZ Member #
    405898
    My Garage
    B9 S4 EVO IX
    Location
    North Carolina

    Roof Rack advice

    Guest-only advertisement. Register or Log In now!
    I need some advice on cross bars.

    I'm interested in a wheel-on bike rack and so far I like the design of the Thule proride. My question is, which cross bars do users recommend? I'm only familiar with Audi OEM, Thule, and Yakima. I'm sure there are other brands out there and I'm willing to consider them. I'm looking for black, areodynamic bars that would work with a Thule bike rack.

    If you have any pics of a bike rack on your S4, please share

    Thule has a pair that look quite sleek, for $560. https://www.thule.com/en-us/us/roof-...r-sedan-_-jm3q


    Audi has a pair listed on the AudiUSA website for $440, but they look like they they add a bit more drag than the Thule option.
    https://parts.audiusa.com/p/Audi_201...8W5071126.html

  2. #2
    Veteran Member Three Rings
    Join Date
    Jun 01 2007
    AZ Member #
    18473
    Location
    NOVA

    So, I had my car delivered with the OEM crossbars because the OEM crossbars that come for free with the '18 SQ5 I had prior really impressed me. They were quiet and easy to install. These were easy to install, but not quiet.

    In the past, I've always been more pleased with the Thule products that I have owned over Yakima. I'm not going to replace these crossbars, but I am going to look into fairing options. If that won't work, I just won't run the rack year round. It's louder on the highway without bikes on the roof than my SQ5 was with two bikes on the roof. The trays are made by RockyMounts.


  3. #3
    Stage 2 Banner Advertiser Four Rings Mops@Nemesis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 28 2010
    AZ Member #
    64971
    My Garage
    '21 SQ5 / '23 S5 / '21 Crosstrek / '23 GTI
    Location
    NW NC / DE

    I run Thule AeroBlade Edge bars with Küat Trio trays on my SQ. I've been extremely pleased. And they both still look pretty much new after a few years in service.

    034Motorsport | ABT | Advan | AG | AWE | BBS | BC Forged | Brembo | Capristo | Deval | EMD | Enkei | Eventuri | Forgeline | Forgestar | GiroDisc | H&R | HRE | KW | Milltek | Rohana | Rotiform | Stoptech | Unitronic | VMR | Vossen | Volk | Vorsteiner and many more!


  4. #4
    Senior Member Two Rings electron bom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 28 2017
    AZ Member #
    405898
    My Garage
    B9 S4 EVO IX
    Location
    North Carolina

    You both have great looking sleds, thanks for the input

  5. #5
    Veteran Member Three Rings mkasperzak's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 16 2014
    AZ Member #
    139158
    My Garage
    Transition Patrol Carbon, Transition PBJ, Commencal Furious
    Location
    Denver, CO

    +1 for the Thule Aeroblade setup. Super clean and offer more adjustability (which I believe matters more on the Q platform). I would steer away from any slotted/euro style bike rack connections. I had a bad failure with my RM euro pitchfork. I’m now running the same Kuat trio racks Mops is running and they are way beefier. Bigger hardware and they wrap all the way around the crossbar, much safer for aggressive driving

    wheels look familiar? lol (Pics are of the Thule crossbars with the old Rocky Mount euro Pitchfork setup)



    2014 SQ5, BBS CH-R, GIAC DP 183 Fluidampr/57 AWE SC(3.18 PR), AWE Touring, Roc-Euro, Bilstein PSS10, 034 HX/X-Brace/RSB/Inserts, Thule Edge/Flow, Kuat Trio

    Build Thread / IG @thebird_sq5

  6. #6
    Veteran Member Three Rings
    Join Date
    Jun 01 2007
    AZ Member #
    18473
    Location
    NOVA

    Quote Originally Posted by mkasperzak View Post
    +1 for the Thule Aeroblade setup. Super clean and offer more adjustability (which I believe matters more on the Q platform). I would steer away from any slotted/euro style bike rack connections. I had a bad failure with my RM euro pitchfork. I’m now running the same Kuat trio racks Mops is running and they are way beefier. Bigger hardware and they wrap all the way around the crossbar, much safer for aggressive driving

    wheels look familiar? lol (Pics are of the Thule crossbars with the old Rocky Mount euro Pitchfork setup)
    What was your failure?

    This was my first purchase of RM, I was able to get two of their Switchhitter trays w/ locks for $200 shipped. I did a 2400 mile road trip in December with my SQ5 and two bikes on the roof and didn't have any issues, including some brief periods over 90mph. They are noisy as hell though, so I may go back to Thule or try Kuat.

  7. #7
    Veteran Member Three Rings mkasperzak's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 16 2014
    AZ Member #
    139158
    My Garage
    Transition Patrol Carbon, Transition PBJ, Commencal Furious
    Location
    Denver, CO

    I had a much older rack than the Switchhitter and it was installed via the T-Track hardware that slots into the Thule T-Track. I'll start by saying I highly recommend RM and their products, just not this T-Track/Euro slotted design that many manufacturers use. I was driving on a gravel road, slowly, and hit a bump and my bike came swinging down on the side of the car. The T-Track hardware literally ripped straight through the Slotted track, metal sheered straight up on the Thule bars (hardware was in tact) and the rear stayed attached but bent up. I talked in depth with both Thule and RockyMount, they were both stellar, great customer service. Thule's stance was we do testing on our own bikeracks and not 3rd parties like RM, they sent me brand new racks both front and rear no questions asked. The owner of RM contacted me directly and walked me thru their testing process. Very long story short he said he has only ever seen this on a few cars in his companies existence and they were a 911 Turbo, M3, and fully modded STI... never an SUV or non high perf sports car. I had this Thule/RM setup on my SQ5 for 2.5 years but I ride my bike 120 days a year and tend to drive rather aggressively. Also had a couple trips to Crested Butte in that time where I drove on off-road trails, tenderly but still it isn't recommended for roof racks to carry bikes off-road (most companies have this disclaimer on website/manual). My point was the roads in Denver can be harsher than some of these backcountry dirt/gravel roads if you avoid rocks/potholes/waterboards and drive slowly. His main point was they test their racks for 10 yrs of abuse, all racks fail its a matter of how long it takes and how much force. RM ensures all their racks will last 10 yrs of abuse on a standard vehicle. Thule does a 40mph crash test, one crash, if it holds, its good in their eyes. His point was the low profile tires, tight suspension, etc all lead to extremely increased metal fatigue.. my 10 yrs took 2.5 yrs. He agreed to pay me back for the Euro Pitchfork racks and adapters I bought over 7-8 yrs ago (were on prior vehicles) and half of my deductible (have comprehensive insurance). Super nice guy, just doesn't recommend those types of racks on high performance vehicles.

    The Switchhitters are dope, my buddy has them. I would just recommend using the hardware that wraps all the way around the bar. Believe you have both options with those.. It is a little less "clean" but way more sturdy/reliable. I'll close with the fact that I've had RM racks on my last two cars (stg2+ B8 A4 & Stg3 WRX wagon both on coils/sways) with zero failures, using the slotted t-track. I'll just won't ever recommend them to an enthusiast with a hi-perf car again. Definitely depends on amt you use them, roads your on, and how you drive. I also have 30lbs Enduro bikes, not 17lbs road bikes.

    Happy Hauling!
    2014 SQ5, BBS CH-R, GIAC DP 183 Fluidampr/57 AWE SC(3.18 PR), AWE Touring, Roc-Euro, Bilstein PSS10, 034 HX/X-Brace/RSB/Inserts, Thule Edge/Flow, Kuat Trio

    Build Thread / IG @thebird_sq5

  8. #8
    Senior Member Two Rings electron bom's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 28 2017
    AZ Member #
    405898
    My Garage
    B9 S4 EVO IX
    Location
    North Carolina

    Quote Originally Posted by mkasperzak View Post
    Transition patrol carbon...

  9. #9
    Veteran Member Three Rings mkasperzak's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 16 2014
    AZ Member #
    139158
    My Garage
    Transition Patrol Carbon, Transition PBJ, Commencal Furious
    Location
    Denver, CO

    Quote Originally Posted by electron bom View Post
    Transition patrol carbon...
    That’s my main squeeze. Hoping to get back on her one of these days, lots of snow lately in the front range


    Sent from my iPhone using Audizine
    2014 SQ5, BBS CH-R, GIAC DP 183 Fluidampr/57 AWE SC(3.18 PR), AWE Touring, Roc-Euro, Bilstein PSS10, 034 HX/X-Brace/RSB/Inserts, Thule Edge/Flow, Kuat Trio

    Build Thread / IG @thebird_sq5

  10. #10
    Junior Member Two Rings Filipao's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 25 2010
    AZ Member #
    68644
    Location
    Estoril, Portugal

    Thule Wing Bar, what else.

    Zero wind noise, perfect fit and style.
    Attached Images

  11. #11
    Veteran Member Four Rings SleeperCar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 03 2012
    AZ Member #
    86119
    My Garage
    VW Atlas and too many detailing supplies
    Location
    Wilmington NC

    bringing this back from the dead....im interested in Thule roof racks for my B9. But i have two main concerns:

    1. i want the roofracks to be low profile
    2. I want to avoid the foot connection from etching into my paint.

    Does anyone have a low profile setup that isnt on a SQ, since the SQ already has rails, its a completely different animal.
    2019 S4 Build

    2013 A4 Scuba Blue Metallic - SOLD (never forgotten)

    IG: @steves_s4

  12. #12
    Veteran Member Four Rings BrockDM's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 21 2018
    AZ Member #
    412780
    Location
    Orland Park, IL

    Quote Originally Posted by SleeperCar View Post
    bringing this back from the dead....im interested in Thule roof racks for my B9. But i have two main concerns:

    1. i want the roofracks to be low profile
    2. I want to avoid the foot connection from etching into my paint.

    Does anyone have a low profile setup that isnt on a SQ, since the SQ already has rails, its a completely different animal.
    I too wanted more of a low profile setup but from what I've found is they all are generally the same height clearance from the roof. The feet design and ability to still tilt the sunroof are the main factors.

    I found the Thule to sit the lowest out of the options I've come across. You're best bet is to try and find a box or rack that has a valley for the rails to sit in rather than on.

    This is my current setup

    Thule 480R feet, 1819 fit kit, 53" Black Wing Blades. The cargo box is a Thule Atlantis 2100 XT. (Old box and will be getting an alpine or INNO in the near future)


  13. #13
    Veteran Member Four Rings SleeperCar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 03 2012
    AZ Member #
    86119
    My Garage
    VW Atlas and too many detailing supplies
    Location
    Wilmington NC

    thanks man, the alpine is actually the box i want, seems like its the lowest profile while also able to fit my families gear when necessary

    based on thule recommendation here is what i have listed so far

    Thule Wingbar Evo 135
    Thule 480R foot pack with fit kit 1819
    Thule Motion XT Alpine
    2019 S4 Build

    2013 A4 Scuba Blue Metallic - SOLD (never forgotten)

    IG: @steves_s4

  14. #14
    Veteran Member Three Rings S4_Pedro's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 17 2012
    AZ Member #
    100624
    Location
    Union

    IMG_6022.JPG this is what I have same as above


    Sent from my iPhone using Audizine

  15. #15
    Veteran Member Four Rings BrockDM's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 21 2018
    AZ Member #
    412780
    Location
    Orland Park, IL

    Quote Originally Posted by SleeperCar View Post
    thanks man, the alpine is actually the box i want, seems like its the lowest profile while also able to fit my families gear when necessary

    based on thule recommendation here is what i have listed so far

    Thule Wingbar Evo 135
    Thule 480R foot pack with fit kit 1819
    Thule Motion XT Alpine
    Yep seems to be the most popular.

    I've been torn between the XT Alpine and the Inno Wedge 660. Leaning towards the Inno tho.

  16. #16
    Veteran Member Four Rings SleeperCar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 03 2012
    AZ Member #
    86119
    My Garage
    VW Atlas and too many detailing supplies
    Location
    Wilmington NC

    Quote Originally Posted by BrockDM View Post
    Yep seems to be the most popular.

    I've been torn between the XT Alpine and the Inno Wedge 660. Leaning towards the Inno tho.
    ok yea, inno looks nice too, i like that they offer gloss white. I was considering paint matching the box glacier white.
    2019 S4 Build

    2013 A4 Scuba Blue Metallic - SOLD (never forgotten)

    IG: @steves_s4

  17. #17
    Established Member Two Rings Denali's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 13 2019
    AZ Member #
    441748
    Location
    Houston, Texas

    I have Thule Aerobars on mine too. Wish they were slightly lower but functionally, it fulfills the needs.

    An engineer who love spreadsheets and cars.

    2018 S4 Premium Plus - Daytona Gray - S Sport Package - ABT HAS - Milltek Non-Res Catback - EPL 93 Oct

  18. #18
    Stage 2 Banner Advertiser Four Rings Mops@Nemesis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 28 2010
    AZ Member #
    64971
    My Garage
    '21 SQ5 / '23 S5 / '21 Crosstrek / '23 GTI
    Location
    NW NC / DE

    Quote Originally Posted by Denali View Post
    I have Thule Aerobars on mine too. Wish they were slightly lower.
    Same. I want them on my Golf R, but cannot get past the height. Just so used to the ABs on my SQ.

    BTW all, as of this week, we're now a Thule dealer, FYI.
    034Motorsport | ABT | Advan | AG | AWE | BBS | BC Forged | Brembo | Capristo | Deval | EMD | Enkei | Eventuri | Forgeline | Forgestar | GiroDisc | H&R | HRE | KW | Milltek | Rohana | Rotiform | Stoptech | Unitronic | VMR | Vossen | Volk | Vorsteiner and many more!


  19. #19
    Veteran Member Four Rings BrockDM's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 21 2018
    AZ Member #
    412780
    Location
    Orland Park, IL

    Quote Originally Posted by Mops@Nemesis View Post
    Same. I want them on my Golf R, but cannot get past the height. Just so used to the ABs on my SQ.

    BTW all, as of this week, we're now a Thule dealer, FYI.
    Convince them to make a flush mount Aeroblade for the B9 and take my money!!

  20. #20
    Veteran Member Four Rings SleeperCar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 03 2012
    AZ Member #
    86119
    My Garage
    VW Atlas and too many detailing supplies
    Location
    Wilmington NC

    Quote Originally Posted by Denali View Post
    I have Thule Aerobars on mine too. Wish they were slightly lower but functionally, it fulfills the needs.

    based on thule pics, it looks like the wing bars dont stick out as far....im not sure though.

    Is that the same foot setup as what i listed above, the 480R? if so, no offense to your setup, but i really dont like that the bars stick out farther than the feet. maybe im overly picky...
    2019 S4 Build

    2013 A4 Scuba Blue Metallic - SOLD (never forgotten)

    IG: @steves_s4

  21. #21
    Established Member Two Rings
    Join Date
    Feb 13 2016
    AZ Member #
    368682
    Location
    NJ

    I have the OEM bars on mine




    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  22. #22
    Established Member Two Rings Denali's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 13 2019
    AZ Member #
    441748
    Location
    Houston, Texas

    Quote Originally Posted by SleeperCar View Post
    based on thule pics, it looks like the wing bars dont stick out as far....im not sure though.

    Is that the same foot setup as what i listed above, the 480R? if so, no offense to your setup, but i really dont like that the bars stick out farther than the feet. maybe im overly picky...
    No worries, I feel the same way. I have the 480R foot with the 53 inch roof bars and they do protrude a bit. I think you can get away with 47 inch bars. You should only see less than an inch at most on either side with the shorter bars.

    An engineer who love spreadsheets and cars.

    2018 S4 Premium Plus - Daytona Gray - S Sport Package - ABT HAS - Milltek Non-Res Catback - EPL 93 Oct

  23. #23
    Veteran Member Four Rings JBAeroEngineer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 19 2012
    AZ Member #
    100756
    Location
    Capitol Area

    bumping this thread since I just picked up the WingBar Evo and can confirm the 47" bar fits the 37" front and 34" rear spacing requirements. The 47" bar only comes with a 36" measuring ruler so just eyeball it. From what Thule said I won't be able to use the kayak lift, but that's ok!
    2018 A4 | Mythos | Prestige | S

  24. #24
    Active Member One Ring SBCID's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 23 2021
    AZ Member #
    635461
    Location
    New England

    Quote Originally Posted by JBAeroEngineer View Post
    bumping this thread since I just picked up the WingBar Evo and can confirm the 47" bar fits the 37" front and 34" rear spacing requirements. The 47" bar only comes with a 36" measuring ruler so just eyeball it. From what Thule said I won't be able to use the kayak lift, but that's ok!
    Thanks for posting this! I have been trying to figure out what length will work best (and look best) on my B9 for the past few months. I just ordered my WingBar Evo and Clamp Evo from my favorite ski shop. I'll post a some pics once I install them for the winter!

  25. #25
    Veteran Member Four Rings JBAeroEngineer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 19 2012
    AZ Member #
    100756
    Location
    Capitol Area

    Quote Originally Posted by SBCID View Post
    Thanks for posting this! I have been trying to figure out what length will work best (and look best) on my B9 for the past few months. I just ordered my WingBar Evo and Clamp Evo from my favorite ski shop. I'll post a some pics once I install them for the winter!
    Happy to help, just keep your use case in mind.
    2018 A4 | Mythos | Prestige | S

  26. #26
    Established Member Two Rings
    Join Date
    Dec 17 2017
    AZ Member #
    411263
    Location
    Chicago

    Bringing this tread back to life. Who is running a fairing with OEM racks? The wind noise is horrendous.

  27. #27
    Active Member One Ring SBCID's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 23 2021
    AZ Member #
    635461
    Location
    New England

    Quote Originally Posted by barthez View Post
    Bringing this tread back to life. Who is running a fairing with OEM racks? The wind noise is horrendous.
    My coworker use to run one on his Q5 with the OEM racks. It helped with noise but the fairing would loosen up over time and bounce in the wind. The thing wore right through the paint to bare metal on the roof.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  


    © 2001-2025 Audizine, Audizine.com, and Driverzines.com
    Audizine is an independently owned and operated automotive enthusiast community and news website.
    Audi and the Audi logo(s) are copyright/trademark Audi AG. Audizine is not endorsed by or affiliated with Audi AG.