Consider: If the OEM design already failed once, is replacing it going to provide a better part?
Maybe, if it was simply a bad part. Or, it will simply fail again if the design was inadequate.
Bending over plastic tabs is cheap fast assembly and it may be good enough for mass-market goods, where those values count. Soldering metal ends caps on, or welding metal end caps on, would increase cost tremendously, so that ain't gonna happen. And the factory won't glue the end caps on, because glue is expensive, and glue that sets up quickly (so you don't have to store inventory while it is curing) costs more money.
But, for the individual owner, a tube of epoxy (regrettably the silicone contaminates the surfaces and needs to be cleaned) and putting it aside overnight to cure is just a $5 expense. Cheaper than the sales tax or shipping on a new part. And, once the end cap is properly attached, it will have zero chance of failing the way the original one did.
So replacing the OEM part which is of questionable durability, is an unreliable solution, unless the end cap is better attached.
Now, if you wanted to go aftermarket and install a totally better intercooler...then by all means, don't fix it, replace it with something better. The pros and cons of messing around with aftermarket turbo parts for any car being a whole other barrel of monkeys. (Sometimes, the OEM systems are designed by competent engineers and snuck into production before the forensic accountants can start cheaping out the designs.)
And Charles has a point: as with all parts on an engine, if you make a whole, plug it. If you remove a MAF, tape over the hole, if that's upstream of the air filter.
And if silicone is the usual acid-curing type, avoid using it around metal components at all. If it smells like vinegar, it can emit enough acid to attack some metal parts and sensors.
Bookmarks