
Originally Posted by
WsmataU
Since it is my thread, I'll take it off course :P
Here's the story: I just moved to OH from FL. I'll be here for about 3-4 years before going back to DC. So, I want a fun AWD car. I'm currently DD my wife's 2009 328i, which is ok, but starting to show it's age. I've got upgrade-it is, but am not in a rush to buy let's call the timeline 6 months. I don't really like the newest batch of BMWs and have always liked the subtlety of the Audis. I (wrongfully) assumed the RS5 was an upgraded S5. I have a '67 Shelby Mustang sitting in the garage if I want attention or really want to bang gears. This car needs to be both reliable and "luxurious" while still maintaining a fun factor.
Here is my thought process for a DD:
I definitely want an AWD car.
It HAS TO have a usable back seat (daughter 5yrs old)
An S5 has manual transmission (+)
An RS5 has the V8 (++)
Neither have the interior that brought me to the Audi mark(-)
I've always liked the lines of the S5, even more than the B9 (but I haven't seen a B9 in person)
The diamond stitched interiors really caught my eye.
The S6 has everything but is "bigger" (S4 is too small) It is also a little boring as far as aesthetics go.
I'm looking in the $50k range (preferably lightly used). What would you pick and why?
My basic criteria are not too different from yours. I need to have a daily driver that holds the family comfortably and that goes fast, fast.
In terms of size:
I had an RS5 convertible up until I totaled it in an accident a few weeks ago. My two boys, 8yo and 6yo, never had a problem getting in and out of the back seat. For the past couple years, both were using just the booster seats. Both were in full-size car seats when I first got the car. Getting those into the car was doable, but a bit of a pain, unless I did it with the roof open, in which case it was stupidly easy.
The other thing I'll throw out there is that, IMO, the interior appointment in the B8 or B8.5 is light years better than the B9. The B9 looks like it has moved downmarket on the interior kit (switchgear feels cheap; lots of vinyl instead of carbon fiber, etc.). The electronic wizardry is way cooler in the B9, provided you get the virtual cockpit. If you get the standard cluster, I doubt you'd see much difference.
I'm in an RS7 now. The kids definitely like the 4 door better. The interior is very nice. The electronics are last generation relative to what is in the B9, but a generation ahead of what was in my B8.5. But, if I wanted to buy the coolest computer on wheels, I'd have bought a Tesla P100d.
Bookmarks