Shocking amount of traffic on downpipes recently. I remember researching this a while back so I figured I'd post up my experiences to the extent it is useful anyone weighing their alternatives (I am far from an expert, but know a lot more about this car than I did a year ago thanks to this forum so hopefully can be helpful to someone). For background, I have installed both APR and AMS downpipes on my car.
My opinion:
- they are both good, but neither is perfect (more on that below)
- realistically, downpipes are probably more of a sound mod than anything. I believe this is the case because if a stage 1 RS7 doesn't need downpipes, why the heck would a stage 2 s6/7 require them? Doesnt make any sense. I'd be willing to be a stage 2 rs7 doesn't actually need them either (limeypride's car hasn't blown up yet). maybe you reduce cat longevity and a tiny bit of power, but that might be it [note: that entire bullet is entirely unproven conjecture based on anecdotal evidence]
My experience with APR:
- Reason to use these downpipes: If you (1) are going for a better sound, (2) want stage 2 software, and (3) plan on keeping your stock catback, these downpipes are a very good deal. As oly and ryan mentioned, use the spacers even if you go with an APR tune so that if you have to flash back to stock you won't throw a CEL.
- Negatives: (1) the cats under the drivers seat and o2 sensors in the middle of the car scream 'tuned!' -- if you want to flash back to stock and take your car to a dealer for something, it will be very obvious as soon as the car is on a lift and could get them curious what else has changed. And no one ever sees it, but the o2 sensors hanging out under the car look a little bootleg which bothered my ocd nature. (2) even with a lot of adjustment, I found the bend going from the engine bay area to under the drivers seat very tight with the underside of the car. I don't know if it actually rubbed, but something to be watching when you do your install.
My experience with ams:
- Reason to use these downpipes: (1) want better sound, (2) dont mind spending $ to buy stage 2 tune separately, (3) like the ability of passing emissions testing without hassle, (4) would like to be able to take the car in for warranty work with much less concern over what the techs might notice, and (5) are considering an aftermarket cat-back. These downpipes are much sturdier / thicker steel than the others (not sure whether that's good or bad, but they feel more solid).
- Negatives: (1) primarily due to the larger cats and likely also the thicker steel, these are an EXTREMELY tight fit with the bulkhead/firewall even if you re-seat the firewall perfectly. It does not touch all the time, but it will almost certainly rub in certain circumstances, which has the potential to cause intermittent vibration issues. Until someone shows me a picture of AMS downpipes which do not have a char mark from the firewall, I will continue to believe this is a minor design flaw (I've seen another install and it had the same telltale marks on the AMS cats from random rubbing against the bulkhead). (2) is that the drivers side AMS downpipe kisses up again the transmission at the bottom flange. This is probably not an actual problem given the DP's are bolted to the transmission anyway, but annoying nonetheless.
That's my 2 cents -- if you want to change the sound of your exhaust, get some downpipes. Depending on your circumstances and what you care about, either one could be right for you. They are both good products (albeit both with what I perceive to be minor flaws). I did not notice any difference in performance between the two and they both sound about the same with my AWE touring exhaust (probably slightly less drone with AMS, though neither is very bad in this regard).
Bookmarks