
Originally Posted by
neveret
so why not just use one of these?
these?
That ATP stock location turbo is not bad, but the 'kit' has been out for a long time and it's the cast, log style manifold that has caused issues for a bunch of the Mk5 BT guys. It doesn't flow evenly and creates some kind of pulsation. Something to do with uneven runner length since the turbo doesn't mount in the center. It's cheap too at $2250, but the GT2871 turbo is outdated and is going to flow less than the turbos in the CTS kit. The GTX series is good for 20% more power than a GT series turbo of the same size, and the GTX will spool up about 400 RPM sooner too. The $800-1000 extra for the CTS kit would be worth it IMO just for the better turbo, plus you get a better manifold, and wouldn't have to create your own turbo outlet pipe. The ATP kit is made for a transverse (GTI, A3, TT) so it doesn't come with the TOP.

Originally Posted by
neveret
Additionally, why would you want to connect to the factory intercooler with a turbo this size? Pardon me for being confused by the appeal of oem+ fit/look. It seems to me the car would likely be moved from the daily driver column to current projects after the clutch and fuel system fall short and like I said you end up with car with marginal power gain over k04 variant systems with a less usable power band.
Not the factory intercooler, just factory location, meaning you don't have to manufacture custom charge piping between the turbo and intercooler. This also includes the turbo outlet pipe, which is not included with the ATP kit.

Originally Posted by
neveret
I'd just argue that the k04 variant turbos hit the sweet spot with these cars for power/fun/reliability/money invested. Maybe you're thinking about making your car into a race machine and in that case again, pardon me.
The k04 is great, but I'm sure some people would like to hit that magic 400 awhp number, which hasn't happened yet on a K04, not even with w/m or E85 I believe. Slowone11 made 410awhp (corrected for elevation), but that's on a Loba LO400 hybrid turbo and custom UM software.

Originally Posted by
Militant-Grunt
Pag Parts Turbo has a kit that utilizes a slew of EFRs and Garretts if anyone is looking for more meat.
I'd put the PPT in a league above hybrid turbos like the Loba and even this CTS BOSS turbo. Also comes in at $4,200 not including software. It also says it's only for transverse, FWD configurations. I'm sure the kit is built to the best standards and highly capable though.
Bookmarks