Not to question your math, but I can't think of a reason for a wheel maker to offer otherwise identical wheels with offset specs varying by just 2mm. Is there a chance one is wider than 9"?
That said - either spec is fine, and the overall 'stance' will be darn near identical to stock. 9" with a 255/45 is perfectly fine - most tire makers spec a max width of 9.5" for that tire.
(EDIT) You know, just in case, there are other factors to consider as well when shopping for aftermarket wheels. Here's the full stock spec, FWIW:
20 x 8.5, ET33, 66.6mm hub diameter, 5x112 bolt pattern; lug bolts are 14x1.5x30mm R14 ball seat.
Your spec confirms the hub diameter (which should negate the need for hubcentric rings, but check with the wheel vendor just in case) and bolt pattern. The offset spec is close to OEM, but if you'd like to see it in graphic form, here's a great link:
http://www.willtheyfit.com/index.php...2=9&offset2=35
The right lug bolts are just as important. In my experience, most aftermarket wheels (including a lot of quality replica products) use a different spec. In this case, the critical element will be the seat type (radius or cone) and the number associated with it. If the aftermarket set calls for different bolts, your wheel vendor may sell them, or at least will be able to provide the spec. (Keep this in mind too if you use a wheel lock kit - you'll need to buy that new as well to match the spec for the aftermarket wheels.) Here's a link:
http://www.mcgard.com/index.php/auto...olts/lug-bolts
One last thing, since you're tire shopping. Factor in the load rating requirement. I believe the Q5 calls for a 101 spec at minimum, but this should be in the owner's manual. I believe the Extreme Contact DWS in this size (255/45) is @ 105, so you should be fine, but it's definitely something to consider. Audis are not lightweights, and the Q5 is no exception. When you load up with passengers and/or cargo, this is not something you want to think about.
I hope that helps....happy shopping, and post some pics!
Bookmarks