For $50 less than what the dealer wanted for a replacement H6 battery, I got an H8 battery. 95A instead of 75A and that translates into about 1/3 longer life as well. For the $200 in labor for installation and programming, I bought the VCDS software and now own it. So...there's "OINK!" and there's "OINK OINK!" and I just refuse to pay that.
If I didn't have extensive experience with 12v systems and the issues they gloss over, I wouldn't have had any idea how "wrong" the Audi mystique is. AGM batteries, according to everyone who makes them, simply must be treated differently if you want to see their full capability. And that can routinely mean 8 years instead of 4 years. The fact that my original battery dies at 14 months I can understand (extenuating circumstances) the fact that the replacement only lasted 3-1/4 years before the dealer decided 12.2 volts is too low to keep the car happy....No, I've spoken to too many engineers at too many companies to fall for that.
With car batteries, the general principle for the charging system is "Do not overcharge the battery". This from an engineer at a company you would recognize. He said their priority was at that time wet lead SLI batteries. And SLI batteries are designed to cycle between 90-100% state of charge (SOC) no further. If you leave it parked with loads (security system, tracker, etc.) for a month at a shot...it cycles below 90%. Sometimes to 60%. The battery gets insulted. And the alternator cuts back very quickly, because they are not rated for continuous duty, and they are designed to cut back quickly so that you can drive all day, ten hours on the highway, without overcharging the battery. That works, most of the time for most folks, who don't complain if they have to replace a battery every 4 years. Oh wait, they lease cars now, they never get that far.(G) Now that batteries are pushing two hundred dollars not seventyfive dollars...the difference between 4 and 8 years means a lot more.
Having seen, programmed, worked with, commercial charge control systems? I was amazed at all the information VCDS shows. Voltage at different points, current flow, estimated SOC and charge condition...it LOOKS like a high end charge control system would be reading all that. If they are just reading it but doing a dumb old two stage charge, and just using the other information to shut the alternator down early (supposedly they do this to release drag on the engine and gain a little mpg) then they are truly wasting an opportunity. AGM batteries, unlike wet lead, prefer to be 100% charged when at rest. Not 90%, not 95%, but 100%. And in exchange, they can go further between charges. They aren't magic though--a properly maintained wet lead battery can get the same 8 years, if charged and watered properly.
Now that the old battery is out of the car and on a proper dedicated charger? Funny thing, the voltage has come back up. The CCA capacity tests also run higher. The Audi? Eh, I think the phrase is "Lucy, you got some 'splaining to do!"
Bookmarks