
Originally Posted by
Hdale85
Any updates on the new unit? I haven't ordered anything yet, probably just going to wait for a bit now. I did install new JL C1-650 speakers with adapters, and foam rings so they seal nicely and boy do they sound better lol. Installing the sub tomorrow.
sorry, it's taken me some time to write everything up. Wanted to give a good overview of the 8" / full touchscreen units I've tested so far.
All units have a lot of commonality:
- 8" full touchscreen with capacitive buttons for power, home, volume (and either Nav or back)
- Android 9.0 OS
- support radio (no HD or SAT), BT phone/media, multiple inputs (reverse + front camera)
- support steering wheel contols (work out of box, can be customized/remapped)
- integrated Wifi (802.11n 2.4GHz) and BT (limited to handsfree, A2DP, and ODB functionality. ODB Eleven may or may not work)
- 1024x600 high-gloss screen (exacerbated by gap between LCD and touch digitizer)
- horrible noise on line-level outputs, requiring use of line-level converter(s)
As for the differences between units
- ZBARK YHAPX501 (edit: unit appear to be the same XTRONS now selling, model IB89A4APL)
Specs: PX5 SoC, MTCE MCU. 4GB RAM/64GB eMMC flash
Pros:- MTCE MCU -> can run custom Android OS
- Has Audi-specific connectors - no adapter harnesses needed (except to use factory GPS antenna)
- Compact unit, lots of space behind
Cons:- PX5 now older generation
- Built-in quadlock connector means slightly difficult to wire in line-level adapters
- No DSP -> meh sound quality (can be improved with modified MCU firmware)
- Has Nav (vs back) capacitive button, less useful IMO (can be remapped though)
- Erisin ES6274A
Specs: PX6 SoC, STM32 MCU. 4GB RAM/32GB eMMC flash
Pros:- PX6 latest generation SoC, quite speedy
- Price - a good bit cheaper than other units
- Compact unit, lots of space behind
- HDMI output
Cons:- STM32 MCU -> can't run custom Android OS
- Wifi antenna is a single 2" wire
- No rear line-level outputs, so extra rewiring needed for Bose systems
- No DSP -> meh sound quality, EQ app does some weird shit (apparently it's a fake EQ)
- No removal tools included
- Antenna adapter single fakra, non-amplified
- track prev/next steering wheel controls didn't seem to work with 3rd party Android Auto dongle
- doesn't appear to have a sleep/low power mode; only option is to delay shutdown (up to 1hr). So long boot (15s) on startup after 1hr
- CarExc (no model #)
Specs: PX6 SoC, MTCE MCU. 4GB RAM/64GB eMMC flash (other SoC/RAM/eMMC configs available - avoid older MTK/PX5 versions)
Pros:- PX6 latest generation SoC, quite speedy
- MTCE MCU -> can run custom Android OS
- Has DSP, fairly decent sound quality once tweaked (best of 3 by far)
- Built-in CarPlay/Android Auto functionality (wired or wireless) works better than an external dongle
- sleep mode works properly
- OBD Eleven works
Cons:- Large chassis with lots of wasted space, makes fitting wiring harnesses/adapters a bit of a pain
- Wifi antenna was badly soldered / shorted, terrible SQ until I fixed it (only 1 of 10 units I've had seems affected)
- Antenna adapter double-single fakra, not keyed to fit stock antenna connector (fixed in subsequent shipments)
- cost: unit is $400, a bit higher than other two
edit: this unit now comes in a 9" / no bezel version:
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000558329933.html
All of the units required some tweaking:
- Added an anti-glare screen protector, cut to fit (217mm x 117mm) [Amazon]
- Wired in line-level converters to speaker outputs [Amazon] (desolder included wires / solder wires from unit)
- Added a dual fakra antenna adapter [Amazon] (cut tab to fit stock connector)
- Added a SMC to fakra adapter to use factory GPS antenna [Amazon]
- Users with an older Symphony II radio will need a additional FAKRA antenna adapter
Taking all of that into consideration, I'm sticking with the CarExc model due to PX6, DSP, and ability to run custom Android OS. If there was another unit available with same specs but a more compact chassis or better screen I'd switch to that, but right now I'm not seeing anything better.
I'm still waiting on my reverse camera trunk handle, but already wired one into my wife's old A3 prior to selling and it worked reasonably well -- better than no camera for sure.
Some pics:
screen without anti-glare film:
anti-glare film added:
Android Auto, night mode (pre-filter install)
Car Launcher Pro
"Built-in" CarPlay/AA module on CarExc unit:
back of Erisin unit, after wiring in line-level adapter and removing excess wires/plugs:
back of CarExc unit, after wiring in line-level adapter and removing excess wires/plugs:
(has two line-level adapters since going into Bose system - for now at least)
Bookmarks