Audizine - An Automotive Enthusiast Community

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 40 of 46
  1. #1
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Roof Rust Repair "Build" (with pics)

    Guest-only advertisement. Register or Log In now!
    Good day! I'm making this thread to have an interactive comment system while my buddy and I undergo extensive rust repair on the roof on my daily driver :)

    I'm hoping to receive constructive comments to help obtain a better outcome with this project. We have no professional experience in this area, we're just common tinkerers using good judgement and striving for perfection. I'm posting another thread for bumper repair as well. Once complete (and if the repair is a success) I plan to make a DIY for this repair as I have seen none for it on the forums and I believe it to be a common problem that most people take to a shop to deal with. I will accredit all who make a relevant contribution.

    Thanks for your input!

    Disclaimer: I do not recommend anyone follow the steps I am about to lay out. As mentioned before, my buddy and I have no professional experience and all the work we are doing is irreversible. At least wait for our finished product.

    So, when I first bought my car, the paint just had MANY flaws, some big, some small. The roof, for instance, seems to have lost it's clear coat and is fading. We've tried some polishing/protective compounds and no real luck (worked on my trunk). The roof rails and water channel-ways had minor to intermediate visible rust bubbling up from under the paint. Our goal in doing this project is to remove the rust from the whole roof (basically just rail edged and water ways) and then fill repaired areas to keep it water tight, then remove the paint on the roof to the metal and repaint it black. Some of this procedure is made up as we see what works.

    Materials used so far:
    -100 grit sand paper (and block)
    -120 grit on an electric sander
    -Straight pick
    -Flathead screwdriver
    -Steel wire brush
    -Vacuum
    -Dremel with grinding attachments
    -Naval jelly (or equivalent)
    -Rust inhibitor spray
    -Painter's tape

    Initially I tried to tackle this project on my own in my shitty assigned parking space in the sun at my apartment. At the time, I thought the only existing rust was what I could see from the surface. So I started on the worst spot. I taped it off, sanded it down and picked out all the rust, then applied the jelly (two coats), flushed it out, wire brushed it, cleaned the surface, and sprayed the inhibitor. The inhibitor is very easy to sand off, but is perfect for saving all the work you've just done until you have an opportunity to start up again. Very helpful, especially here in Hawaii.



    When you spray the inhibitor, it prevents the rust from spreading by suffocating it. It sprays on clear and turns the bare metal and rust black. Like I said, easy to sand off.

    Lucky for me, I went to my buddy's house (with a garage) to remove my front bumper (next thread). He decided he would help me clean out the rust and started on the other side. He discovered the side walls of the rail (short but necessary) were weakened by the rust and in some areas rusted all the way through. He also pulled up the end of the channel guard and discovered that the rust (mostly surface further down) appeared to go below the channel guard. We started on the visible rust and then called it a day.



    These last two pictures may be out of timeline as I only decided to do this thread on the third day (yesterday).

    Yesterday I went to AoH and talked to a tech there about some of the work I was doing. He assured me (98%) that pulling up the channel guards would not promote water leakage into areas that shouldn't have water and that the purpose of the guard was to cover up the welds underneath. Upon closer inspection (and pulling up the guards) I agree with him. The guards are tucked under the trims of both windshields, so they're not deferring the water from those...and there are absolutely not stock openings in this area (only those created by our rust removal).

    We used a combination of electric sander, hand sand paper, dremel grinder, wire brush, and vacuum to remove as much rust as possible. Very tedious and daunting task. Definitely not for the impatient. We weren't able to remove all the rust in the hours of work for yesterday, but we still jellied and laid the inhibitor down to save our work. We also used a gasket sealer (Honda, boooo) :) to fill the holes to keep water from coming out. As with most silicone fillers, they are very good at being water tight and also very easy to remove once dried (perfect temporary solution, just what we needed).

    Here are the pictures from yesterday.













    Definitely still a work in progress. At this time, I'd appreciate any CONSTRUCTIVE criticism. If you have any advice or tips or can see anything that we're doing morbidly wrong or could do better, we would much appreciate it. Thanks for your time (I know it's long and not completed) and I hope this proves to be beneficial to you all.
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  2. #2
    Established Member Two Rings builditup's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 24 2011
    AZ Member #
    71437
    Location
    VA (757)

    Man i have the same issue on the wagon i just bought. It's only two little spots, but i cant wait to see your finished product. Looks like your doing it right so far. Good luck.
    1996 A4 v6 fwd 5spd 165k (sold)
    2000 A4 v6 Quattro auto 122k (sold)
    2002 A6 wagon v6 Quattro auto 141k(sold)
    2004.5 Duramax 4dr 51k (straight axle, chip.....ect)
    2008 Colorado ext cab 98k I4 (work/dd)
    AUDIless for now....

  3. #3
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    Just a heads up...there is no need to remove the paint on the roof to bare metal. If there is rust on the roof than that is a different story but if there are just minor scratches and gashes then just sand them and feather them out. If there bad enough (dented) then fill them and block it flat. Remember always match your block size to your dent size or repair size. If the dent is a foot long don't use a 5 inch block because your not going to get flat body work. But overall if the rust isn't going all the way through then all you need to do is grind it all out and fill it and sand it with a coarse paper and keep going finer until about 180-320 for primer. Then block that primer flat with a sanding block that matches the size of the area and then use a soft padded orbital or DA sander to go over it with a finer paper. And you can even wet sand that after with a 800 grit or so and get it really nice. Remember don't just try to fill it all with one coat of filler. It could take a few coats to get it perfect. And don't leave any deep pin holes or you'll be pissed at the final product. Good Luck!
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  4. #4
    Veteran Member Three Rings cjonesgo's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 22 2007
    AZ Member #
    18238
    My Garage
    02 A4 Avant 1.8t qm, '74 Vespa
    Location
    oakland ca

    Someone else will hopefully know more about this and chime in, but doesn't audi have a 12 year corrosion warranty/coverage?

    I know you are well into the project, but may be worth looking into at least. Perhaps can get material costs covered?
    [CENTER]02 A4 Avant 1.8tqm Dolphin Gray
    Blackout Grills | S4 Bi-Xenons | 3.0 Brakes | RS4 Rear Swaybar | Bilstein Sport Shocks
    K04 | REVO | TT225 Injectors | Apikol SMIC | 034 HFC |

  5. #5
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    BTW maybe I read wrong but you can save a lot of time but using a hand grinder on these rust areas. Using 100 grit by hand is a bit of work.
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  6. #6
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by builditup View Post
    Man i have the same issue on the wagon i just bought. It's only two little spots, but i cant wait to see your finished product. Looks like your doing it right so far. Good luck.
    Thanks for the encouragement. Rust is both ugly and damaging. I hope I can give you enough detail (and success of course) to fix yours. Thanks again.

  7. #7
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    Just a heads up...there is no need to remove the paint on the roof to bare metal. If there is rust on the roof than that is a different story but if there are just minor scratches and gashes then just sand them and feather them out. If there bad enough (dented) then fill them and block it flat. Remember always match your block size to your dent size or repair size. If the dent is a foot long don't use a 5 inch block because your not going to get flat body work. But overall if the rust isn't going all the way through then all you need to do is grind it all out and fill it and sand it with a coarse paper and keep going finer until about 180-320 for primer. Then block that primer flat with a sanding block that matches the size of the area and then use a soft padded orbital or DA sander to go over it with a finer paper. And you can even wet sand that after with a 800 grit or so and get it really nice. Remember don't just try to fill it all with one coat of filler. It could take a few coats to get it perfect. And don't leave any deep pin holes or you'll be pissed at the final product. Good Luck!
    Didn't know about the different block sizes for filler sizes. Good call, thanks. I do know about pin holes though...we're gonna be as patient and as thorough as necessary. Although I plan on this being temporary until I move to the mainland and get a garage of my own and do a full paint job, I still want it to last and look good. And I'm gonna have to refer to your post again when it comes time for sanding. Bare metal may not be necessary, just didn't wanna short change myself. May end up revising that. And I was just using hand sand paper on the light areas while my dremel battery recharges. Thanks a lot man.

  8. #8
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by cjonesgo View Post
    Someone else will hopefully know more about this and chime in, but doesn't audi have a 12 year corrosion warranty/coverage?

    I know you are well into the project, but may be worth looking into at least. Perhaps can get material costs covered?
    I took my car to AoH two days after I bought it to redeem warranty items. All it qualified for was the coil pack replacemant. Car had been previously repainted same stock color. Thanks though.

    How do you like your bilstein/H&Rs? What springs are they? Happy with the height? How much space between tires and fender?

  9. #9
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    Quote Originally Posted by gottaBdope View Post
    Didn't know about the different block sizes for filler sizes. Good call, thanks. I do know about pin holes though...we're gonna be as patient and as thorough as necessary. Although I plan on this being temporary until I move to the mainland and get a garage of my own and do a full paint job, I still want it to last and look good. And I'm gonna have to refer to your post again when it comes time for sanding. Bare metal may not be necessary, just didn't wanna short change myself. May end up revising that. And I was just using hand sand paper on the light areas while my dremel battery recharges. Thanks a lot man.
    A lot of body guys or as we call them "butchers" will use a block about the size of your hand to block primer or sand body filler that is roughly as long as your arm and get a finished product of something you can surf on. Guys that are really good can feel the panel by hand and feel the little imperfections and know how much to take off and what not. But remember when working with body filler the expression in the shop I work at is "The block don't lie". The block will tell you if you need to put another coat of body filler on or not by seeing the high and low spots.
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  10. #10
    Veteran Member Three Rings cjonesgo's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 22 2007
    AZ Member #
    18238
    My Garage
    02 A4 Avant 1.8t qm, '74 Vespa
    Location
    oakland ca

    Quote Originally Posted by gottaBdope View Post
    I took my car to AoH two days after I bought it to redeem warranty items. All it qualified for was the coil pack replacemant. Car had been previously repainted same stock color. Thanks though.

    How do you like your bilstein/H&Rs? What springs are they? Happy with the height? How much space between tires and fender?

    Actually swapped out the H&R's back to the stock sport suspension, but guess I never updated my sig. oops.
    I was never really that happy with the ride honestly. They were lower than stock sport, but felt stiff without providing any appreciable performance gains. The car seems to handle just as well at stock height, but feels infinitely better for the daily grind. I don't track my car, but doubt I would see much improvement if I did. I do still have the Bilstein shocks, and RS4 rear swaybar, and am happy with the balance between everyday driveability and sporty feel on twisty roads. I do miss the lower ride height and may opt for a set of these in the future.
    [CENTER]02 A4 Avant 1.8tqm Dolphin Gray
    Blackout Grills | S4 Bi-Xenons | 3.0 Brakes | RS4 Rear Swaybar | Bilstein Sport Shocks
    K04 | REVO | TT225 Injectors | Apikol SMIC | 034 HFC |

  11. #11
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    A lot of body guys or as we call them "butchers" will use a block about the size of your hand to block primer or sand body filler that is roughly as long as your arm and get a finished product of something you can surf on. Guys that are really good can feel the panel by hand and feel the little imperfections and know how much to take off and what not. But remember when working with body filler the expression in the shop I work at is "The block don't lie". The block will tell you if you need to put another coat of body filler on or not by seeing the high and low spots.
    Hah, butchers. What is the suggested ratio of filler to block sizes?

  12. #12
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by cjonesgo View Post
    Actually swapped out the H&R's back to the stock sport suspension, but guess I never updated my sig. oops.
    I was never really that happy with the ride honestly. They were lower than stock sport, but felt stiff without providing any appreciable performance gains. The car seems to handle just as well at stock height, but feels infinitely better for the daily grind. I don't track my car, but doubt I would see much improvement if I did. I do still have the Bilstein shocks, and RS4 rear swaybar, and am happy with the balance between everyday driveability and sporty feel on twisty roads. I do miss the lower ride height and may opt for a set of these in the future.
    Perfect! Actually never knew these existed. Car had blown H&R coilovers when I bought it, so I replaced the shocks/struts with the bilsteins and kept the springs. But since the springs in the back are separated, They're still adjustable. The spring seat for the driver's rear spring broke from the threading...so I need to find something like this for the rear.
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  13. #13
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    Quote Originally Posted by gottaBdope View Post
    Hah, butchers. What is the suggested ratio of filler to block sizes?
    There is no ratio. Just match the length of your filled area to your block. I mean you don't have to get down to a tenth of an inch but generally the rule of thumb is to match the size of your block to the size of the area your repairing. If you ever watch any custom car shows and see the body guys doing the work...if they are blocking a hood (sanding it flat) they may have sanding blocks 4 feet long to make sure everything is flat. Basically all it is doing is helping you achieve an extremely flat body because if there are any high spots or low spots they will be magnified when paint is applied.
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  14. #14
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    There is no ratio. Just match the length of your filled area to your block. I mean you don't have to get down to a tenth of an inch but generally the rule of thumb is to match the size of your block to the size of the area your repairing. If you ever watch any custom car shows and see the body guys doing the work...if they are blocking a hood (sanding it flat) they may have sanding blocks 4 feet long to make sure everything is flat. Basically all it is doing is helping you achieve an extremely flat body because if there are any high spots or low spots they will be magnified when paint is applied.
    Makes sense. Didn't know there were 4ft blocks...hah, got a lot to learn. Any advice on what to use as filler? All I know of is the whole bondo line, which has mixed opinions.

    Also looking for some painting pointers...don't exactly have a booth set up...
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  15. #15
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    Quote Originally Posted by gottaBdope View Post
    Makes sense. Didn't know there were 4ft blocks...hah, got a lot to learn. Any advice on what to use as filler? All I know of is the whole bondo line, which has mixed opinions.

    Also looking for some painting pointers...don't exactly have a booth set up...
    I work at a body shop. I do mostly paint prep, scuffing bumpers and panels and light body work and car detailing. I am not an expert at body work but I know the basics and enough to make a car look very nice. Also what might a good investment for you if you wind up getting into any more body work on the car and even when your blocking your primer on your roof is what is called a guide coat. It comes in a powder and brush and you apply to your sanding area. It shows your low and high spots once your start sanding and will guide you on where to sand and where you may have to fill a bit more.

    The filler we use at our shop I believe is Marson. http://www.google.com/products/catal...d=0CL8BEPMCMAU
    Any of the name brands should work fine like 3M.

    And for painting pointers...I don't paint cars myself but once again since working at the body shop since I was young you see things done and can pick up the basics.
    Buy a good spray gun like SATA or something that may cost you a few bucks but will be well worth it the end.
    Don't use cheap products when painting. We use all Sherwin Williams products when we paint.
    Take your time masking off your car and try to paint in an area that doesn't have a lot of dust. Easier said than done. A trick we use is to wet the floor when we spray at our shop which will keep the dust down and not raise off the floor. Make sure you run a tack rag over the area you want to paint before hand.
    And read the directions for whatever paint your using whether it be PPG, dupont, sherwin williams etc...learn what reducer to use depending on what temp your painting in.

    Obviously your not going to be perfect when you start but just go on youtube and look for videos on body work and painting and you will pick up quite a few pointers. I do it all the time. Good Luck!
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  16. #16
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    And after its all said and done you will want to invest in a good buffer because you probably will have some screw ups like runs/dust in the paint that can be sanded and buffed to make them gone. Also learn what psi you should be operating your spray gun at. It's not so much the painting thats hard...its the prep work that takes time.
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  17. #17
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    I work at a body shop. I do mostly paint prep, scuffing bumpers and panels and light body work and car detailing. I am not an expert at body work but I know the basics and enough to make a car look very nice. Also what might a good investment for you if you wind up getting into any more body work on the car and even when your blocking your primer on your roof is what is called a guide coat. It comes in a powder and brush and you apply to your sanding area. It shows your low and high spots once your start sanding and will guide you on where to sand and where you may have to fill a bit more.

    The filler we use at our shop I believe is Marson. http://www.google.com/products/catal...d=0CL8BEPMCMAU
    Any of the name brands should work fine like 3M.

    And for painting pointers...I don't paint cars myself but once again since working at the body shop since I was young you see things done and can pick up the basics.
    Buy a good spray gun like SATA or something that may cost you a few bucks but will be well worth it the end.
    Don't use cheap products when painting. We use all Sherwin Williams products when we paint.
    Take your time masking off your car and try to paint in an area that doesn't have a lot of dust. Easier said than done. A trick we use is to wet the floor when we spray at our shop which will keep the dust down and not raise off the floor. Make sure you run a tack rag over the area you want to paint before hand.
    And read the directions for whatever paint your using whether it be PPG, dupont, sherwin williams etc...learn what reducer to use depending on what temp your painting in.

    Obviously your not going to be perfect when you start but just go on youtube and look for videos on body work and painting and you will pick up quite a few pointers. I do it all the time. Good Luck!
    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    And after its all said and done you will want to invest in a good buffer because you probably will have some screw ups like runs/dust in the paint that can be sanded and buffed to make them gone. Also learn what psi you should be operating your spray gun at. It's not so much the painting thats hard...its the prep work that takes time.
    Thanks man, lots of good advice. My brother back home has been studying up on this stuff for a while, I've just been a little lazy to try and piece the whole thing together. Wasn't until the last week that I actually began to fulfill this "dream." We shall see how it goes.
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  18. #18
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Just an update for those who care:

    Didn't have the motivation to do anything today. Our new couch and such arrived today, and I think that justifies a lazy day. So I went down to the garage and just put three coats of the inhibitor on, which might I say is impressing the shit out of me. My biggest worry about doing this kind of work was that I knew we couldn't do it all in one session and it's my daily driver...so I was very concerned with the spread of the rust as we exposed more metal...but this shit is amazing! It even acts as a nice clear coat beautifying all the scars we've added to the car...not too shabby Mr. Inhibitor.
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  19. #19
    Senior Member Three Rings blackfc3s's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 15 2010
    AZ Member #
    65739
    My Garage
    Custom build 29er Mountain Bike
    Location
    Nebraska

    audi has a rust warranty

  20. #20
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by blackfc3s View Post
    audi has a rust warranty
    Yup. But as I enlightened earlier in this thread, it's a strict warranty and if you've had any body/paint work, then the warranty is voided. POs had the whole car repainted same color (Dolphin Grey) either after a fender bender or when the body kit was installed. I already checked in to it. Good lookin' out though.
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  21. #21
    Established Member Two Rings RSicks's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 20 2012
    AZ Member #
    86940
    My Garage
    03 A4 Quattro 3.0
    Location
    Napa, CA

    gottaBdope, when you took off your drip moldings... did you happen to notice if you will be able to reuse them or is that something that needs to be replaced once removed?

    Also, was the drip moldings hard to remove? I am thinking about pulling them up and not sure the process and cannot find a DIY on the net anywhere.

  22. #22
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by RSicks View Post
    gottaBdope, when you took off your drip moldings... did you happen to notice if you will be able to reuse them or is that something that needs to be replaced once removed?

    Also, was the drip moldings hard to remove? I am thinking about pulling them up and not sure the process and cannot find a DIY on the net anywhere.
    According to AoH (who called them channel guards) they do no sell replacements and it wasn't even listed as a parts option. It wasn't hard to pull up at all, just carefully pry up one end with a screwdriver and then pull the whole thing up slowly (metal guard and rubber grommet thing). But when you pull it up, it bends, very malleable. AoH said you should be able to reuse the old one, as long as your rubber is still good and you can manage to bend the metal portion back to place. The guard is just there as cover up from the welding. It doesn't perform any function of water tight and the rubber is there to keep the water from sitting under the metal cover. My point is, this part isn't extremely necessary and is an awesome opportunity to add some creative customization. We haven't figured out exactly what we're gonna do yet. We used a grind wheel to derust and depaint both channels, so I'm sure the rubber won't wedge perfectly in there yet. However, just filling the whole channel in isn't an option either because when your car hits bumps, the frame tweaks ever so slightly, but enough to crack something thick and solid like a filler. We're trying to figure out what a good, clean, and effective solution is, so I'll def post when we do. Hope this helps so far.

    When you pull the channel guard out, you will realize just how much rust is in there. For my car, this is the only portion of rust that I've found, but it took my buddy and I a little more than two hours (working both channels at the same time with separate grinders) to get all the rust out. We talked to a body shop for advice and they said it's a major weak point on these cars. They won't give any guarantee that they can remove all the rust. If you decide to take this on, just know you'll have your work cut out. Lemme know if you got more questions.
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  23. #23
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Well, after getting off track for a little while on this thread, I'm ready to resume the original purpose.

    I've accomplished a lot in my absence and because of that have been way too tired to post any of it...till now.

    So, in a nutshell, my buddy and I removed the channel guards, sanded down the whole channel on both sides of the car using sand paper, grinder, and wire wheel. Some of this resulted in holes in the channel in order to completely remove the rust. Since we didn't finish everything in one day, we would fill the holes with silicone gasket and then spray the whole channel with a rust inhibitor. Every time we resumed, we would remove the old inhibitor and continue with the rust extraction.

    At this point, we have completely removed all the rust and sprayed a galvanizing primer to cover the bare metal. The benefit of this primer is that not only will it prevent any rust from forming, it's also extremely durable to endure the weather during this rest period, and it's thick enough to double over as a sand-able primer filler. I am very pleased with our progress up to this point. Here are some pictures to illustrate what I have just described.




















    From here, I plan to remove the gaskets and fill with a body filler, then sand down the primer. We haven't decided on how to finish the channels. Don't know how easy it is to refit the stock channel guards into the channels after a) they've been mishaped from removing them and b) the channel may not be as snug after all the work we've done to them. If anyone has any ideas or has done anything to their channels that might be an option for this case, please lemme know. Very open to suggestions.

    Thanks for checkin' up! Don't know how long until I update this project again...got multiple projects going on at once :-D
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  24. #24
    Veteran Member Four Rings walky_talky20's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 30 2008
    AZ Member #
    30427
    Location
    Erie, Pennsylvania

    Holy overspray, Batman. I'm sure you've realized this, but you need to run that paper out wider next time. Otherwise, great work. This looks like a pretty ambitious project.
    ^Don't listen to this guy, he's not even a mechanic.
    2001 Laser Red A4 1.8TQM, 5-Speed Swapped, 4.11 Final Drive, APR 93, 2.5" Exhaust, ST Coilovers, 034 RSB, A8 Brakes Front & Rear
    2006 Passion Red Volvo V50 T5 AWD 6MT
    2000 Satin Silver Passat 1.8T FWD Wagon, Slippy Tiptronic, 15" Hubcaps
    2001 Aluminum Silver Metallic A4 Avant 1.8TQM (winter sled)

  25. #25
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by walky_talky20 View Post
    Holy overspray, Batman. I'm sure you've realized this, but you need to run that paper out wider next time. Otherwise, great work. This looks like a pretty ambitious project.
    Hah hah. Yeah, I mainly just wanted to cover the bare metal with something that would be weather resistant. The inhibitor wasn't doing an excellent job...

    I had my car parked at a garage under a car port while I was swapping the power steering hose out, but I finished it yesterday and didn't wanna pay to keep it there while I slowly completed this process, so...this is what I go I suppose...

    I'm def gonna sand it down and try to fade it into the existing paint and recover it...making it up as I go along :-D
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  26. #26
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    I don't know if you are doing this or not but make sure you are feathering out where you've grinded the paint off and where it meets the bare metal. Smooth it all out and makes the lines smooth so you wont see it when its all painted. This would have been ideal to do it before you primed it because now you have to sand back down to the metal areas and feather them out properly and then reapply primer.
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  27. #27
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    And you should really have any open holes welded shut it you want it done properly but since this is not an area you will see you can probably get away with just filling the smaller sections depending on how large they are.
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  28. #28
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    And you should really have any open holes welded shut it you want it done properly but since this is not an area you will see you can probably get away with just filling the smaller sections depending on how large they are.
    I'm kinda getting this groove of one step forward, then one back, then two forward, then one back and two and so on. I think it's just the cost of taking on multiple projects. The holes are pretty small, four for the whole car. Largest one being 2" x 1/4". Weldin would be ideal and may still be an option, but I may need to fill some grooves in with filler anyways and may be better to just get the holes that way. Not sure. Gonna sit on it for a little while while I finish some other things.

    Thanks.

  29. #29
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    Quote Originally Posted by gottaBdope View Post
    I'm kinda getting this groove of one step forward, then one back, then two forward, then one back and two and so on. I think it's just the cost of taking on multiple projects. The holes are pretty small, four for the whole car. Largest one being 2" x 1/4". Weldin would be ideal and may still be an option, but I may need to fill some grooves in with filler anyways and may be better to just get the holes that way. Not sure. Gonna sit on it for a little while while I finish some other things.

    Thanks.
    Its definitely not an easy task but its looking good so far. Take your time and do it right!
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  30. #30
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    Its definitely not an easy task but its looking good so far. Take your time and do it right!
    Thanks. Time is the best thing I have going for me right now.

  31. #31
    Veteran Member Four Rings diagnosticator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 26 2005
    AZ Member #
    7741
    Location
    Seattle, WA

    Your Audi has a 12 year rust through warranty. It's too late now, but you could have checked with a dealer about the rust problems before tackling the repairs on you own.
    Vorsprung durch Technik

  32. #32
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    Quote Originally Posted by diagnosticator View Post
    Your Audi has a 12 year rust through warranty. It's too late now, but you could have checked with a dealer about the rust problems before tackling the repairs on you own.
    I think that because the car was painted it voids the warranty.
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  33. #33
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by diagnosticator View Post
    Your Audi has a 12 year rust through warranty. It's too late now, but you could have checked with a dealer about the rust problems before tackling the repairs on you own.
    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    I think that because the car was painted it voids the warranty.
    Correct. I took it in for the coil pack recall the day after I got it and I asked them to check for the paint recall too...within two feet of the car the guy could already tell that it wasn't stock painting. It had been wrecked on the driver's front quarter panel and I think repainted when some PO installed the body kit. I can't take pictures to bring justice to the hideousness of the blemishes on that car. Some of the areas leave me speechless as to how they got to what they are now. Hah. Good lookin' out though guys.
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  34. #34
    Veteran Member Four Rings diagnosticator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 26 2005
    AZ Member #
    7741
    Location
    Seattle, WA

    I am not sure now, but the rust through warranty is really a warranty on the galvanized body, and should not depend on if the car has been repainted or not. I will see if I can find more info on this. However it's only an academic pursuit now.
    Vorsprung durch Technik

  35. #35
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by diagnosticator View Post
    I am not sure now, but the rust through warranty is really a warranty on the galvanized body, and should not depend on if the car has been repainted or not. I will see if I can find more info on this. However it's only an academic pursuit now.
    Alright. Would be a real bummer if it was actually covered. Let us know what you find. Hopefully we can keep others from doing the same.

  36. #36
    Veteran Member Four Rings diagnosticator's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 26 2005
    AZ Member #
    7741
    Location
    Seattle, WA

    The rust inhibitor has chemicals in it that transform the iron oxide (rust) into iron phosphate (not rust).
    Vorsprung durch Technik

  37. #37
    Established Member Two Rings ClutchMaster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 01 2012
    AZ Member #
    89138
    My Garage
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible 5 Speed "Biddie"
    Location
    NY

    how is she coming along?
    2003 Audi A4 Avant 5 Speed--- K and N Air Filter---"Audri"
    1994 BMW 318i Convertible---"Biddie"

  38. #38
    Veteran Member Four Rings
    Join Date
    Mar 17 2008
    AZ Member #
    26539
    Location
    CT

    Based on the pictures it looks like your car had previous body/paint work done.

    Poor prep = rust.

    Good luck with your repairs.

  39. #39
    Veteran Member Four Rings gottaBdope's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 07 2012
    AZ Member #
    91388
    My Garage
    '99 Clown Shoe
    Location
    Colorful, Colorado

    Quote Originally Posted by diagnosticator View Post
    The rust inhibitor has chemicals in it that transform the iron oxide (rust) into iron phosphate (not rust).
    Is iron phosphate in any way harmful?

    Quote Originally Posted by ClutchMaster View Post
    how is she coming along?
    Well, I haven't made any recent progress, but I am pleased to announce that the primer, though oversprayed (which was my goal btw ), is still holding like a champ. I am confident that I have completely rid the roof/car of rust and the bare metal is very contained. Unfortunately, I try to take on too many project at once and can only afford to do so much at a time. 42DD catch can arrives today!

    Quote Originally Posted by Antekaudi View Post
    Based on the pictures it looks like your car had previous body/paint work done.

    Poor prep = rust.

    Good luck with your repairs.
    Yeah...I'm a little embarassed in the car that I agreed to buy. I was sooo stoked to finally get a car that I've wanted for so long that I was able to overlook things that I should not have accepted...like the poor paint and bodywork. For a while I thought I was in over my head, but it's all finally starting to come together...after lots of money and time...hah. I will continue to work though!

    Thanks for all y'alls support!
    ^Rory^

    *2014 Audi S6* <- Daily
    *1999 BMW Z3 Coupe* <- Street-legal Track

  40. #40
    Registered Member One Ring
    Join Date
    Sep 21 2012
    AZ Member #
    100900
    Location
    lynnwood wa usa

    I have the same problem with my two Audis. I have one that is 2003 and 2005 A4's. The Audi A4 2003 looks like that and is almost completely rusted and i had gone to the dealers and they had rejected me because it was " painted before" then i had gone to another shop and they had told me that this was a manufactoring problem. The 2005 A4, has the same problem but i have seen it early on so i can stop it by going to the dealer again to see what is exactly going on. This means that all the cars from the years 2002-2008 with the same roofs and the same connections have problems. They also told me in the shop that there is no way to fix this and that its just going to get worse because of they way that it was manufactored. You could only save the car by constently cleaning it, and painting it to save it at least 15 more years. The Audi company has not made any recalls on these parts of the car. I hope this helps.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  


    © 2001-2025 Audizine, Audizine.com, and Driverzines.com
    Audizine is an independently owned and operated automotive enthusiast community and news website.
    Audi and the Audi logo(s) are copyright/trademark Audi AG. Audizine is not endorsed by or affiliated with Audi AG.