Progress update- I never did figure out why the stock 8E0909518AK .bin file that I cross-flashed onto my 518AF ECU ran so roughly. After some initial troubles, I got the ME7logger GUI working and was able to log some baseline data on my stock tune and got familiar with interpreting the data logs and also with reading the .bin tune files in tunerPro. The .xdf map for the 518AK .bin file is so much better defined than the available .xdf for the 518AF that I decided it would be worth one more try to cross-flash a 518AK bin onto my 518AF ECU since everything I read indicated that should work OK. Rather than re-flash the same stock 518AK.bin that I had already tried and had trouble with, I decided to instead take the plunge and flashed the 518AK based "community 1.8T stage 1 tune" that is well documented and available at;
http://nefariousmotorsports.com/foru...p?topic=6955.0
The 518AK stage 1 .bin flashed easily with nefmoto flasher, started and ran fine, it had none of the rough idle problems that I encountered with the previous cross-flashed stock 518AK .bin file. I refilled my tank with premium octane gas and went ahead and did some testing and used ME7logger to record data from all the engine sensors. I anticipated that the stage 1 tune would need additional adjustment for my particular car but after several logging sessions and 2 weeks of daily testing, I am very pleased with the tuning as-is. It is entirely usable and makes the car much more fun to drive and I really find no faults with the tuning. Even at lower end of the RPM boost range, the throttle response is much faster than stock and the torque available throughout the low to midrange RPM is dramatically better. This stage 1 tune was developed around safety limitations of the stock 240cc/min injector capacity and the flow limitations of the K03 turbo map so the raised boost (around 14PSI max at midrange RPM) then gradually tapers off to near stock levels as the RPM climb toward redline. The stock injectors and turbo cannot support a big increase of the higher RPM peak HP but the increased area available beneath the torque curve from around 2500-4500 RPM is dramatically better than stock, very much reminds me of the instantaneous lower RPM grunt that I had on my old 2.8L B5 before I got my 1.8t B6. My daily commute involves a 7 mile drive up a steep, winding mountain road and the extra boost of the stage 1 tune does a much better job of being able to stay in 3rd gear on the steep sections without needing to downshift in order to keep speed up.
It would be foolish to blindly flash this tune to your engine if you don't have a good sense of what you are doing and if you are not willing to data log and verify that it is working well. The tune does require a healthy engine and premium fuel. Beyond that, I would say that the nefmoto stage 1 is a great starting point for experimenting and learning to tune your own ECU and is an amazing resource for those 1.8T owners from approximately 2002.5-2005, applicable ECUs are 8E0909518AF, 8E0909518AK, & 8E0909518BC. Other earlier/later 1.8T models can still benefit from studying the tuning approach but will need to actually perform the tuning the maps of their ECU accordingly.
Bookmarks