The desire to use a BOV for the "psst" sound on an Audi A4 has dated back to the B5 A4, and that debate has been restarted with each new generation of driver and build. Generally the use of a BOV on a close to stock Audi has been frowned upon because the A4 has been a closed system which utilizes a DV as opposed to an atmospheric BOV. Even
some BT Audis don't need it.
I suggest doing some research on what a BOV does and what types of systems they are good for. Then determine where your car's (the B8) MAF takes it's measurement, if its an open or closed system, and what kind of gains you will get as well as the risk factors for using a BOV on your car.
What does an MAF do? On the B5-B7 A4 the MAF metered the intake air mass. This measurement is used to calculate the required fuel to be injected in order to maintain a proper air/fuel ratio. Because air mass reading is taken from the intake, venting air after the intake makes this reading inaccurate.
What does a BOV do? It releases excess air when the throttle plate is closed so as not to cause excessive stress to the turbo. When a BT setup running lets say 20-30 psi, experiences pressure surges, this can significantly affect the time needed to "re-spool" the turbo, cause premature wear and tear, and even cause damage to the turbo and blowout. Thus, the BOV is used on high performance big boost cars which have been tuned to adjust for the air released by a BOV. For those that know what a BOV does and where it is needed, the sound is associated with highly modified turbo cars. For others, it just sounds cool. Or maybe it sounds cool because we have heard fast cars make that sound?
Why didn't the A4 already come with one if it works so well? I'm not too sure, but the fact that the A4 uses a "closed" system is either a result of or one of the factors of using a DV instead of a BOV. Either way, the MAF and ECU were designed with a closed system in mind.
Note that there are also "spacers" which allow for the BOV sound while still being able to use a DV. The Spacer still makes the system atmospheric, venting air that was measured by the MAF. While some spacers are adjustable, they are still venting metered air.
One such spacer is made by Forge Motorsport, who expressly state that:

Originally Posted by
Mike@ForgeMotorsport
We have NEVER claimed there to be any power or performance gains from this product, HOWEVER, along with everyone's (valid) concerns as to the venting of metered air, it is important for us to provide evidence that we have offered a product that does not negatively effect performance in any way.
source:
http://forums.vwvortex.com/zerothread?id=2651617
To summarize, the B5-B7 A4 was not designed to use a BOV or Spacer. The Spacer, which when used in conjunction with a DV, vents metered air, thus providing BOV functionality. The spacer/BOV has not been shown to improve performance in the 2.0T FSI and the manufacturer makes no claims that it will. Thus the BOV almost purely cosmetic for the B5-B7 engines with the stock KO3 running 8-9psi.
What's wrong with a purely cosmetic mod? Nothing. But I do have the opinion that a mod should not misrepresent or give false impressions of the car it is placed on. This would include such mods as false badging (ie S4 badges on a A4, Turbo badges on a NA car) and fake BOV generators such as this:
Fake Turbo Sound Whistler
The Fake Turbo Sound Whistler does not hurt or increase performance. It's purely cosmetic and a complete misrepresentation of the car it's placed on. I wouldn't say that a BOV on a stock A4 is as much of a misrepresentation or nearly as reprehensible. But, taking into consideration that the BOV is designed for big boost turbo setups running, for example, 20-30psi, it is my opinion that the BOV would be a misrepresentation of my vehicle unless I am actually generating those kinds of numbers. There are those who think it's fine to make others think that their vehicle produces the boost levels that require the use of a BOV when they, in fact, do not, but I am not one of them. On the other hand, there are those who don't even know what a BOV truly does or when it is needed, so there is no misrepresentation at all. The sound is just "cool". IMHO that does no service to the enthusiast crowd as a whole, because the entire meaning of the mod is closer to being lost to nothing more than a cosmetic sound. I don't know about you, but that doesn't sound like the ideal way to promote the community.
In the end, you make your decision. What is important to me may not be important to you. Take as many facts you can into consideration when you make your decision, and know that not everyone is going to agree with your decision or appreciate your mods, and they may have a good reason in their own mind.
Bookmarks